SEO is so amazingly believable it could be bunkum

Raise your hands brothers and sisters if you believe. Say “I believe”…again, say “I believe”…one more time brothers and sisters…say “I believe – I believe in the greatness that is SEO”. For many people who are running an online business, search engine optimization (SEO) has taken on almost religious levels of faith. Tell people that SEO is nonsense and they look at you like you are a devil worshipper.


Is search engine optimization all it is cracked up to be?

Is search engine optimization all it is cracked up to be?

But new sociology research from the University at Buffalo in New York State suggests we may believe in the power of SEO because we only seek information that confirms our thinking. As soon as we find data or information that makes it possible that an alternative viewpoint exists, we mentally head for the hills, denying the new material. In fact the study shows that people essentially ignore any information that presents a contrary view to the one they already hold.

Although this study was focused upon political views, it shows that once a group of people get an idea in their head, it is very difficult to shift that notion – even if the view is confirmed as false. The study showed that the false belief that Saddam Hussein was involved with the 9/11 atrocity still persists – in spite of evidence showing that this could not be the case.

Consider then the whole area of “search engine optimisation” – SEO. Wherever you look there is simply tons of support for it. Indeed, Google serves up more than 31m indexed pages for it and if you check on keyword monitoring services, such as Wordtracker, you’ll find hundreds of variations of phrases using SEO, search engine optimization and so on. Clearly, it is a hugely popular topic.

But this new research raises the possibility that it is all bunkum, that we have a false belief in the goodness of SEO, which is merely constantly confirmed because we deny the existence of any information which dares to suggest that SEO might not work. In other words, we think that SEO is wonderful because we only see the “evidence” that confirms that belief.

Whenever you dare to criticise any aspect of Internet technology, along comes someone to tell you that you don’t know what you are talking about and that it certainly worked for them. Maybe. But maybe something else could have worked better. That’s the problem with SEO; it’s relatively easy to get good results, which only then “confirms” that it works – further helping us have faith in what may well be a falsehood. And, as a result, endless numbers of people can tell you it works. But maybe something else could work better.

Search engines, of course, have an interest in indexing stuff that promotes the apparent value of SEO. This leads to us seeing a considerable amount of information supporting the view that SEO is excellent, which in turn helps confirm our belief that it works. In other words, just as with many other popular ideas, the ever circular arrangement of supporting material, confirming our view, which then creates more supportive material is simply a way of helping us believe in something that is false.

The essential thing to always have in mind is whether or not SEO works for you, your marketplace, your customers, your products and your specific circumstances. Because it works for one of your products or services does not mean it will work for another. Just because SEO works for one of your networking contacts, doesn’t mean it will work for you.

In other words, don’t have blind faith in SEO – question it, test it and analyse it. If you don’t, you could well end up believing it is working, when in fact it isn’t. And as this New York State study shows, you will never even know it isn’t working because you will shut your mind to the evidence that it is failing.

The only way out of this conundrum is to test every aspect of your web site, to analyse the data and act on the information you glean from evidence. Mere faith will get you nowhere online.

Like this article?

Share on twitter
Share on Twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on Linkdin
Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on email
Share via email

Other posts that might be of interest

Internet Psychology

Is your brain back to front?

British businesses will spend this weekend on tenterhooks as they wait for Monday’s announcement from the Government about the ending of lockdowns. For the past couple of weeks, the mutterings from 10 Downing Street suggest

Read More »
Internet Psychology

Can you do boring tasks?

Last week, not far from the M25 in Buckinghamshire, the biggest-ever boring machine in the UK started its slow churn through the Chiltern hills to dig a tunnel for the HS2 rail system. It will

Read More »
Fence painting
Online Business

When did you last paint your garden fence?

If you are a “big change” business, then you are like my garden fence. Leaving it unpainted for so long has created much more work, at a higher cost, than if it had been tended to every year. Ignoring reviews of your online activity for long periods also means you make more work for yourself and raise your costs.

Read More »