This site is dedicated to helping you understand online behaviour by providing you with blog posts, articles, news items, multimedia and downloads on web psychology

Advertisers have been making a fundamental mistake

Pay Per Click AdvertisingOnline advertisers are keen to tap into what we are thinking about. Go onto Facebook and the adverts will be for things that you are currently, apparently interested in. Similarly, surf the web and you will discover that the adverts you see are all for things you have recently searched for. The idea is that because you are thinking about these things you must be interested in them.

If that were really true, of course, then online advertisers would get a much higher click-through rate than is currently the case. Indeed, the vast majority of online advertising is ignored. The only reason that the advertisers actually gain anything from them is because a tiny percentage of billions of views still adds up to lots of money.

New research, however, suggests that taking a completely opposite approach to the conventional online advertising wisdom could well yield more money from smaller numbers of people.

The study found that contrary to expectations, people are most intersted in something they have not been thinking about when it is presented to them. The researchers from the University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus presented people with pairs of words and asked them to think about just one of them. Later on they were given several words to look at and were asked to point out any they identified. The word identified by the participants was the one they had NOT been thinking about, but the other one in the pair. A similar effect was found when people were presented with two pictures. When asked to identify a picture it was the one they had not spent time thinking about that jumped out at them.

In other words we appear to notice things more easily when they are not on our minds. This is the complete reverse of what advertisers think is the case. They focus on what is on our minds and then give us the opportunity to click on their advert. But we don’t – and now we know why. It is because it is on our minds that we are not interested.

Advertisers need to advertise things we are currently NOT interested in. That way we are more likely to notice them. Far from trying to track what we are currently thinking about, the online advertisers ought to be doing the opposite. It appears that the online advertising industry is unable to get the click-throughs it really wants because it is doing the opposite of what they should be doing. True, what they are doing is logical – indeed the Nottingham researchers were convinced that they would not find what they did.

Dr Matthew Johnson from Nottingham University said: “The effect was shocking. When we began we expected to find the exact opposite – that thinking about something will make it easier to identify. We were initially disappointed – but when the effect was replicated over multiple experiments we realised we were onto something new and exciting.”

, , ,

2 Responses to Advertisers have been making a fundamental mistake

  1. Dr. Brian monger 14th July 2013 at 4:01 am #

    Have I missed the title and details of this research? Is it published?

  2. Graham Jones 14th July 2013 at 8:15 am #

    Hi Brian

    It is due to be published in “Psychological Science” soon – I received the information directly from the University of Nottingham. Once I see it is published I’ll add a link to the post.


Home | Blog | Articles | Newswire | Multimedia | Downloads | Newsletter | About | Contact | Speaking | Press | Accessibility | Privacy | Cookies |

VAT No: 348 4830 29 | Tel: 0118 336 9710 | Kemp House, 152 City Road, London EC1V 2NX

Some of the links on this page are Affiliate Links and lead to sites where I can earn commission income should you buy anything.
Graham Jones is a participant in the Amazon EU Associates Programme, an affiliate advertising programme designed to
provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to
This site uses cookies. For more information please see the Privacy page.
Most images are used under license from iStockphoto, GraphicStock or Fotolia

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.