Should you take notes or rely on AI to help you?

Published:

Category:

Note taking at an event

On Wednesday, I was at the theatre in London and I wish I had taken notes. I was with my son at “Only Human”, the latest amazing show from the talented mentalist and illusionist, Derren Brown. Derren appears to do the impossible, and we puzzled for ages on how he might have achieved what he did on stage. If only I had taken notes, I might have been able to work out how he tricked us. 

However, that might not be the case as I discovered later on in the week. Having recently retired from my full-time academic career, I thought I should go through my collection of notebooks and remove anything that was no longer relevant or useful.  Sadly, there were pages of notes that were indecipherable. They contained words in English that made sense individually, but together seemed like a string of nonsense. No doubt at the time I wrote them they made sense. Then there were pages of material which were illegible, presumably written in the darkness of a conference hall. 

I shredded hundreds of pages that contained sensitive information and once that was done I threw away all seven notebooks I had collected. Out of all those notebooks I managed to save just a couple of items that were useful. It made me wonder why I had spent so much time taking notes at meetings and events. If all I did was to eventually throw them away, what was the purpose of taking notes?

Indeed, thinking about my note-taking habit and its outcome, I felt rather guilty about recommending the idea to students. Not only was I wasting my time writing notes, but I could also have been misleading students about the potential benefits.

Does note-taking actually work? 

Luckily, there is evidence that note-taking by students leads to higher marks in subsequent tests when compared with students who did not take notes. There is also research that shows memory is improved when we take notes. So, note-taking does work, up to a point.  

Other studies show that when we take notes traditionally in handwriting, our brains become more stimulated than when we use a keyboard or our phones. Canadian psychologists also conducted a review which suggested that one of the reasons we are less good with computerised note-taking is the level of distractions available. Your paper notepad can’t send you notifications that an email has just come in.

However, there is a problem with taking notes. You have to pay attention to three things at the same time. You have to write notes about something that has just been said, focusing on the past. At the same time you have to listen to what is being said now, in the present. You also have to conduct a third action, which is deciding what to make notes about after you have finished writing the current note, focusing on the future. Research shows that when we have to split our attention in this way it causes interference in the completion of the tasks. That explains why some of the notes I threw away made no sense. I was probably listening more to what was being said which was interfering with my ability to write something sensible in my notebook.

Some people suggest it is all to do with the note-taking system being used. Most people just write linear notes, jotting down things in the order they occur. Others are enthusiastic users of mind-maps to build up a visual picture of a meeting, for example. Some are wedded to academic systems like the Cornell Method.  But whatever system you use, you are still writing about something that has just happened while listening to something new. Is it any wonder my notes made little sense? I suspect if you were to go back through those notebooks gathering dust in the corner of your office, you may well find the same thing. You have spent hundreds of hours of your life dutifully making notes you don’t use, which may well have meant you were not listening to what was being said.

Enter stage left, Artificial Intelligence.

Let AI do the listening 

Claude Meetings, for example, can join your Google video calls and listen in to take notes for you. That allows you to concentrate on the event. ChatGPT can create notes from audio recordings of your meetings. Gemini can join in on Google Meet calls and take transcripts directly to summarise them. You are not short of options for using AI to make notes for you. 

You can also use recorders like Plaud or Pocket to record your events and produce your notes. These save you the effort of having to write your notes, allowing you to listen closely. You no longer have to split your attention. 

Before you hand over every meeting to a machine, though, remember those hundreds of pages I had to shred. Handwritten notes stay in your drawer. AI notes sit on someone else’s servers, and that includes every confidential remark about clients, staff, and money. You also need the agreement of everyone in the room before you record them, and not every client will be comfortable with a bot listening in. Then there is accuracy. AI tools mishear names, muddle who said what, and smooth over the nuance of a tense discussion. A summary can look tidy and still be wrong. So, AI note-taking solves the problem of split attention, but it brings problems of its own. 

Why notes can make you forget 

There is also an issue we tend to ignore about note-taking itself. This was discovered in experiments conducted over a decade ago. These showed that people who took notes remembered less than people who did not do so. It turns out that in some instances, when we take notes we decide not to try to store things in our memory. We assume that the notes are our memory. But if all we do is hide that notebook away, we won’t have anything to recall. Indeed, many of those studies that suggest note-taking helps have a common thread. They show that the people who had the best results from note-taking were the ones who went over the notes again and again.

In other words, when we take notes, we give ourselves permission to forget, and we only overcome that by going back over them afterwards. So, try this at your next meeting. Let an AI tool do the capturing, with everyone’s agreement, and give your full attention to the people in the room. Then, before the day is out, spend five minutes reading the summary and jot down the three things that matter most, in your handwriting. That is the step that builds memory, and it is the one most of us skipped in all those notebooks.

Mind you, none of this would have helped me at the theatre. Derren Brown’s techniques are designed to stop me remembering the very moments that would reveal how he fooled me. Even the best notes in the world would not have saved me.